Skip to main content

Balancing Act

Too often I find reporters trying to strike a balance in their reporting by publishing comments that have little news value.  For example, take the following quote from an article in the New York Times about possible Republican health care proposals.  The comment seems to have little to no news value and sullies an otherwise useful article about the types of proposals that might become part of bipartisan health care reform:

Representative George Miller, Democrat of California, said, “If the Republicans’ health care plan was a plan for a fire department, they would rush into a burning building, and they would rush out and leave everybody behind.”

The statement is inflammatory.  It is contradicted by the article.  It does not benefit the national discussion on healthcare.  It allows partisans a cute sound bite for avoiding the debate about whether our nation should invest in sweeping changes, incremental improvements or more of the same.  Surely there is at least one Democrat who can provide a reason why Republican ideas are too little, too late.  Is there no one willing to make an argument in favor of doing nothing?

Reporters need to strike balance by offering opposing insights, not a forum for opponents to hurl insults that neither educate nor enrich.

Thelma and I purposefully don't get any cable news channels.  If I want to watch news coverage (and I happen to be home at the right time) then I'll tune into PBS NewsHour  It's balanced, long-form reporting.  Reporters take the time to cover issues in depth and don't seem to betray much of a bias one way or the other.  Part of the program is dedicated to commentary from analysts with differing view points who know how to have a respectful conversation about substantive issues without it turning into a yelling match.  The host actually moderates the discussion.

Compare that to the buffoonery of Fox News and MSNBC where the hosts try to be both the center of attention and the final word on all topics.  The crumbs of rational and passionate debate are buried beneath an avalanche of populist rhetoric and political theater.  Fair and balanced?  Rarely.  The days of Brit Hume at Fox News and Brian Williams at MSNBC are long gone.  What passes as balance is yelling on the right to offset the cries coming from the left.  Or is it the other way around?


(Here's where I insert plugs for my favorite news sources.  First, The Economist.  It covers the full gamut of business, politics, science, education and culture.  It's published once a week so the reporters have time to look at the big picture and avoid being blinded by the haze of up-to-the-minute reporting.  Second, the New York Times is simply the best newspaper in the United States with its breadth of coverage and quality writing.  The Op-Ed pages present a nice contrast between the leftish editorial board and intelligent Conservative commentary.)
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Block Facebook Ads with CSS

(This is my experience evaluating Facebook for my daughter.  It turned into a technical exercise in CSS.  If you want the full narrative, read on.  If you just want the steps for using CSS to block ads on Facebook, jump ahead .) Emma asked permission to create a Facebook account so she can keep in touch with some of her cousins and friends.  Emma has been very responsible using our family computer and does a good job keeping our rules about what to do and how to behave online.  So, Thelma and I decided that it was probably OK once I had a chance to check out and become familiar with the privacy settings and parental controls. Even though I work for an online business and Facebook is a frequent topic of conversation when it comes to reaching out to and retaining online customers, I have to admit that I have rarely used the service.  I created an account for business purposes to become a "fan" of a client so I could keep tabs on some social marketing campaigns.  That's it. ...
3 comments
Read more

Awake. Again.

I arrived home from work with just enough daylight and just enough Spring to mow the lawn.  Braeden and I reveled in the straight lines and greening blades.  "It's the awakening," he said. — I sat in the temple and smiled at the sight of Emma and Braeden sitting side by side, quiet and content.  Outside the temple, we stared up at the stained glass, the angel, the glowing walls.  I asked Emma how she felt.  "Light and airy," she replied. — Driving home from the airport, I listened to my mother describe her trip to Disneyland with Megan, Talia and Jackson.  "If your dad were still alive..." she began to say.  For the first time, I smiled and laughed instead of fighting back tears. — Awake. Light. Laugh. Alive. Again. — Everyone is asleep.  I sit down to write.  I don't cry.  I don't turn away.  It's a change.  I can write again, at last.  But it's not the same as Before.  Everything seems differ...
3 comments
Read more

Helped or Had

I feel uneasy tonight. I'm not sure if I helped or was had. In what has become something of a Thursday-evening-post-basketball tradition, I drove to Walmart for some late night shopping. Two weeks ago it was new shorts and an exercise shirt. Last week it was another exercise shirt (because I liked the first one so much). This week it was new insoles and laces for my basketball shoes. (Thelma, who has thoroughly documented her distaste for shopping at Walmart has driven me to these shopping trips under the cover of night.) Approachable is not how I would have described myself as I trudged across the Walmart parking lot in my wife-beater sleeveless shirt, shorts and coordinating fleece vest. Sweaty, yes. Beleagured, perhaps. Approachable, no. But a woman did approach. Something told me to stop and wait for her. She was caught somewhere between out-of-breath and verge-of-tears. I could see she was nervous talking to me. She tripped quickly over some desperate story that I co...
3 comments
Read more